Choose Etsy if you want to sell within a shared marketplace, and Shopify if you want an independent storefront and can plan how to attract customers. Etsy search can create discovery opportunities without guaranteeing traffic or sales. Shopify gives you greater control over store presentation, but customer acquisition remains your responsibility. The better fit depends on those operating needs as much as on fees.
For US sellers, the financial choice also involves different cost structures: Shopify Basic combines a subscription with payment processing, while Etsy charges for listings, transactions, and payment processing, with additional fees when particular conditions apply.
Shopify and Etsy solve different selling problems
Shopify is a platform for operating your own online store. Etsy is a marketplace where your listings appear alongside those of other sellers. That distinction changes both the environment customers shop in and the work you take on.
| Decision factor | Shopify | Etsy |
| Selling environment | Standalone, seller-operated store | Shared marketplace with seller listings |
| Customer discovery | Seller plans how to attract visitors | Marketplace search can create discovery opportunities |
| Store presentation | Greater control over an independent storefront | Presentation within Etsy’s marketplace environment and rules |
| Core fee structure | Subscription plus payment processing; third-party transaction fees may apply depending on payment setup | Listing, transaction, and payment-processing fees |
| Operating responsibility | Storefront operation and customer acquisition | Marketplace selling amid competing listings and marketplace rules |
For an operator with an existing audience, Shopify offers a separate destination for that audience. For a seller who wants customers to encounter products while browsing a marketplace, Etsy offers that selling environment. Neither choice eliminates the need to make the products appealing or manage the business behind them.
The useful starting question is therefore concrete: where do you expect your next customers to come from? A platform subscription answers how you will operate a store, not how shoppers will reach it.
Compare US seller fees by their actual bases
As of October 7, 2026, Shopify’s US pricing lists Basic at $39 per month with monthly billing, or $29 per month equivalent with annual billing. Its standard domestic online card rate through Shopify Payments is 2.9% + $0.30.
For a seller with a US bank account, Etsy Payments processing is 3% + $0.25. That processing charge is separate from Etsy’s listing and transaction fees.
| Platform or fee | Published amount | Billing basis or condition |
| Shopify Basic, monthly billing | $39 per month | Recurring subscription billed monthly |
| Shopify Basic, annual billing | $29 per month equivalent | Requires annual billing |
| Shopify Payments on US Basic | 2.9% + $0.30 | Standard domestic online card transaction |
| Etsy listing | $0.20 | Per charged listing event; further listing charges can arise from renewals and quantities |
| Etsy transaction | 6.5% | Order amount, including charged shipping and gift wrap |
| Etsy Payments, US bank account | 3% + $0.25 | Payment processing; the processing base can include sales tax |
| Etsy Offsite Ads | 15% or 12%, capped at $100 per order | Applies to qualifying attributed orders; rate depends on preceding-365-day Etsy sales |
| Etsy currency conversion | 2.5% | Applies when listing and payment-account currencies differ |
Shopify: separate the subscription from each payment
On US Basic, a $100 standard domestic online card sale incurs $3.20 in Shopify Payments processing: $100 × 2.9% + $0.30. The subscription and other business costs sit outside that charge.
The $29 annual-billing figure is a monthly equivalent, rather than the price for a month-to-month subscription. Use the billing arrangement you intend to purchase in your budget.
Payment setup matters, too. Shopify’s standard card rate is not a rate for every card or payment method, and third-party transaction fees may apply depending on the plan and payment setup. The worked example in this article uses Shopify Payments.
Etsy: listing events, transactions, and processing are separate
Etsy’s fee schedule lists a $0.20 listing fee and a 6.5% transaction fee. Listings expire after four months, and renewals, additional quantities, and private listings can generate further listing charges.
That makes the number of charged listing events a separate budgeting input from the number of orders. A seller estimating monthly Etsy costs needs both.
Fee bases also affect the total. Charged shipping and gift wrap are included in Etsy’s transaction-fee base, while payment processing can include sales tax. A calculation based solely on item revenue will miss those amounts when they apply.
Conditional charges can change the margin on an order
Etsy Offsite Ads fees apply to qualifying attributed orders. The rate is 15% below $10,000 in Etsy sales over the preceding 365 days, and 12% at or above that threshold, with a $100 fee cap per order.
The 2.5% currency-conversion fee applies when the listing currency differs from the payment-account currency. These charges have specific triggers; they are separate from the standard listing, transaction, and processing components.
For budgeting, keep advertising-attributed orders and currency-conversion charges identifiable rather than spreading an assumed charge across every sale.
A worked US example: 60 orders at $50 each
Consider a US seller processing 60 separate $50 online orders in one month, for $3,000 total. The Shopify path uses Basic with monthly billing and Shopify Payments’ standard domestic online card processing. The Etsy path assumes 60 charged listing events during the month.
Both paths have no charged shipping, gift wrap, or sales tax. The calculation excludes ads, apps, fulfillment, taxes, refunds, and other costs.
| Platform path | Calculation | Modeled monthly fee total |
| Shopify Basic, monthly billing | $39 subscription + (2.9% × $3,000) + ($0.30 × 60) = $39 + $87 + $18 | $144 |
| Etsy, with 60 assumed listing charges | (6.5% × $3,000) + (3% × $3,000) + ($0.25 × 60) + ($0.20 × 60) = $195 + $90 + $15 + $12 | $312 |
The Etsy total includes $12 for the assumed 60 listing charges. Actual listing events must be counted separately from orders. The calculation uses the published Shopify Basic rates, Etsy selling fees, and US Etsy Payments rate.
What the difference means for an operating budget
Under these assumptions, Shopify’s modeled fees are $168 lower for the month: $312 − $144. Customer-acquisition spending is outside both totals.
That distinction matters to the choice. If operating an independent store requires additional acquisition spending, that spending belongs alongside the subscription and processing charges. Likewise, an Etsy order carrying an Offsite Ads fee needs that charge included when evaluating its margin.
The illustration answers a specific fee question at a specific order volume. Your own budget should substitute your billing choice, order values, charged listing events, payment methods, and fee-triggering conditions.
Customer acquisition and brand control
How shoppers find a Shopify store or Etsy listing
Etsy offers an opportunity to appear in marketplace search while shoppers browse listings. A Shopify seller operates a standalone store and must plan how to attract visitors.
For a seller without an established audience, marketplace discovery may be a reason to consider Etsy despite its layered selling fees. The trade-off is competition with other listings and operation within marketplace rules.
For a seller who already has a way to reach potential customers, Shopify’s independent-store model may fit better. The acquisition plan should be specific enough to budget: identify where visitors will come from, who will manage that work, and what spending it requires.
A handmade business faces the same underlying choice. Making products and attracting customers are separate jobs; the selling environment changes how the second job is approached.
Storefront control changes where the brand experience lives
Shopify offers greater control over the presentation of a standalone store. Etsy places the shop and its listings within a shared marketplace environment.
Choose the independent-store model when control over the storefront is a central operating requirement, rather than a future preference. That control comes with responsibility for operating the storefront and bringing people to it.
Choose the marketplace model when selling within an established browsing environment fits the business. Its convenience comes with shared surroundings, competing sellers, and marketplace rules.
For broader platform-selection context, the Shopify versus Big Cartel comparison examines another standalone-store decision.
Using both platforms as sales channels
A seller can operate an Etsy shop and a Shopify store at the same time. This can diversify sales channels, but it also adds coordination work across listings, inventory, and orders.
The practical question is what role each channel serves. For example, a business could evaluate Etsy as a marketplace-discovery channel and Shopify as its independent storefront. Each needs its own cost and acquisition budget rather than a combined total that hides how the channels perform.
For inventory planning, designate one stock record as the source of truth. Set reorder points around sales pace, supplier lead time, and a buffer, then revisit them as demand changes. This is an operating approach, not a promise that either platform will synchronize the work automatically.
Adding a second channel is most useful when the business can assign responsibility for maintaining accurate listings and stock. More selling destinations also mean more coordination.
Choose for your current operating needs
Choose Shopify if…
- You need greater control over the presentation of an independent storefront.
- You have an existing audience or a concrete plan to acquire customers.
- You can budget for the subscription, payment processing, acquisition, and storefront operation together.
- You want a standalone store to serve a defined role in your sales-channel strategy.
Choose Etsy if…
- Your products fit marketplace selling and you want opportunities to be discovered while shoppers browse.
- You prefer operating inside a hosted marketplace environment.
- Your margins can accommodate listing, transaction, processing, and applicable conditional fees.
- You are comfortable with marketplace competition and rules governing the selling environment.
For handmade sellers evaluating those options, this comparison video offers a related viewing resource.
Before committing, build a channel budget
Use your expected operating month rather than a platform’s headline rate:
- Map customer acquisition. Identify the audience or discovery route each channel will rely on, and assign the work and budget.
- Count orders and listing events separately. Record expected order values, shipping and gift-wrap charges, and Etsy listing charges.
- Apply the intended payment setup. Use the Shopify billing term and processing method you plan to use, or Etsy Payments’ US-bank-account rate.
- Add conditional and operating costs. Include relevant advertising, currency conversion, apps, fulfillment, and other expenses.
- Assign channel responsibilities. If using both, decide who maintains listings, stock records, and order coordination.
Bottom line
The decisive budget is the cost of running the channel and attracting customers—not platform fees alone. An independent storefront gives you more presentation control while adding acquisition responsibility; a marketplace offers discovery opportunities within a shared selling environment.